Go Guerilla Or Look For International Recognition?
Retailer Bosideng opened its first international location in London last month
With a growing number of young Chinese designers debuting collections both at home and abroad — next month, Qingqing Wu will show at Mercedes-Benz Fashion Week in New York while Vega Zaishi Wang shows in Milan — and some domestic brands investing heavily in international expansion, the dilemma for “created in China” fashion hopefuls has never been more stark. Is it better to target China’s billion-plus population, ballooning middle class and fashion spendthrifts or seek acceptance overseas? Does the expectation of greater legitimacy and branding brownie points legitimize the huge risk and expense of international forays for independent designers and ambitious premium labels, or is it more lucrative and sustainable to target a broader base of potential buyers in second- and third-tier cities?
This week, Beijing-based fashion influencer and publisher Hong Huang (previously on Jing Daily) tackles these questions in her WWD ChinaFile column, casting the dilemma for fashion brands and designers as “Mao’s way” versus the “Paris runway”:
As Hong admits, this strategy — while good for faster growth — is limited by the fact that brand licensees regularly drop masterbrand guidelines in terms of design and policies. If sales figures don’t hit preset goals, it’s not uncommon for these licensees to simply drop the brand. These problems, among others, were an instrumental part of the decisions by major luxury brands like Burberry, Sergio Rossi and Dunhill to buy out their China franchising partners in recent years. A lack of brand uniformity, quite simply, hurt their brands and precluded a stronger and more solid expansion push — one that has seen the number of Burberry stores in mainland China swell to more than 50.
Vega Zaishi Wang will show next month in Milan (Image: Nuandao)
Looking at the other strategy for Chinese brands — international cred-seeking, which we’ve recently seen from Bosideng — Hong seems to think this will actually have more of an effect on fashion buyers abroad rather than in China itself:
While Hong’s conclusion (“I wonder, why not both?”) is a bit of a cop-out, the article does a decent job of addressing some of the questions we’ve brought up before, particularly those facing independent designers. Who, for example, will really respond to Bosideng’s international expansion? Do they really think they’ll appeal to a broad swath of British shoppers? Or are these stores simply very expensive advertisements for visiting Chinese tourists, who’ll then (presumably) hold the brand in higher esteem when they return home? Will appearances at Fashion Week in New York, Paris or Milan really translate to a greater fan-base and sales in China for young designers, or will it be more worthwhile to use these appearances as a springboard to sell to fashion lovers in Europe or North America?